Page 2 of 2

Re: nickels worth keeping

PostPosted: Fri Dec 03, 2021 5:29 pm
by Cu Penny Hoarder
Morsecode wrote:My main bank told me I could get a box of pretty much anything (except halves) every week if I put in a standing order. I was thinking of stacking some sealed nickel boxes. Maybe get some Lincolns from another branch to hand search. It's winter, after all. 8-)


I've also toyed with the idea of keeping the boxes sealed, but what fun would that be? :P

I pluck out all pre-1960's and the gemmy looking ones. Yesterday I found quite a few dated 1965 in MS-65+ condition, the luster is amazing. Looks like they were minted yesterday. I love finding coins that look like that. Haven't found any war nickels lately though. :(

A very friendly girl at one of my CU branches does not charge me any extra premiums for the boxes I order. I'll definitely be brining her a few nice Christmas presents this year!

Re: nickels worth keeping

PostPosted: Sat Dec 18, 2021 3:30 pm
by Morsecode
The first week, I got a sealed box.

This week, they broke into "my" box because they were short on inventory. I took home 30 BWR's.

Loose rolls are problematic. I can stare at full stacked boxes and suffer no immediate urges. The plastic bag of rolls called to me this morning and I caved.

I hope this is not the start of something, as the third roll I cracked open yielded a full date 1928. Sandblast appearance, but a still a buffalo. :thumbup:

Re: nickels worth keeping

PostPosted: Sun Dec 19, 2021 12:33 am
by Morsecode
I'll track any future sorting in the appropriate thread, but since I posted here first might as well post the follow up.

$160 BWR's yielded:

67 pre-1963 Jefferson (didn't separate the '64's), 1 really nice '39, 1 decent '53S (mintage 19mil)
1 Canada 1992
1 proof 1979 Jefferson, beautiful condition. Must've just escaped captivity
3 Buffalo, 1 dated 1928..2 dateless, 1 one those is D minted
20 or so various years, nice enough to set aside just because
A handful of Westward Journey (I only saved the better ones)
A smaller group of '82 & '83 which actually aren't worth segregating

What I didn't find:

Any war nicks
Any Canada .999
No 3 legged buffalos (buffaloes?)
No 1913 Liberty :wave:

Re: nickels worth keeping

PostPosted: Sun Dec 19, 2021 5:24 pm
by shinnosuke
Morsecode wrote:I'll track any future sorting in the appropriate thread, but since I posted here first might as well post the follow up.

$160 BWR's yielded:

67 pre-1963 Jefferson (didn't separate the '64's), 1 really nice '39, 1 decent '53S (mintage 19mil)
1 Canada 1992
1 proof 1979 Jefferson, beautiful condition. Must've just escaped captivity
3 Buffalo, 1 dated 1928..2 dateless, 1 one those is D minted
20 or so various years, nice enough to set aside just because
A handful of Westward Journey (I only saved the better ones)
A smaller group of '82 & '83 which actually aren't worth segregating

What I didn't find:

Any war nicks
Any Canada .999
No 3 legged buffalos (buffaloes?)
No 1913 Liberty :wave:


Buffaloes eat potatoes and tomatoes.

Did you find any 2009 nickels?

Re: nickels worth keeping

PostPosted: Sun Dec 19, 2021 8:29 pm
by Morsecode
shinnosuke wrote:Did you find any 2009 nickels?


Not a one. I meant to mention that.

Re: nickels worth keeping

PostPosted: Sun Dec 19, 2021 11:10 pm
by shinnosuke
Morsecode wrote:
shinnosuke wrote:Did you find any 2009 nickels?


Not a one. I meant to mention that.


So sad. Better luck next time.

Re: nickels worth keeping

PostPosted: Fri Jan 21, 2022 7:41 pm
by Cu Penny Hoarder
Opened 2 boxes today. Found many oldies and a few 1939's, but my best find was a 1942-P war nickel and a 1934 buffalo with a nice readable date.

Hurry up and hoard all the nickels you can before they're gone... only a matter of time. :wave:

Re: nickels worth keeping

PostPosted: Mon Jan 24, 2022 3:29 pm
by thecrazyone
It is really crazy how the '09 nickel is so elusive. Who would have known??

I actually did find another one that I'd bought a few years back, or, someone gave to me in a 2x2. At any rate, just glad I have some!!

Re: nickels worth keeping

PostPosted: Mon Mar 07, 2022 12:27 pm
by Cu Penny Hoarder
thecrazyone wrote:It is really crazy how the '09 nickel is so elusive. Who would have known??

I actually did find another one that I'd bought a few years back, or, someone gave to me in a 2x2. At any rate, just glad I have some!!


Found one last week. MS condition.

Re: nickels worth keeping

PostPosted: Thu Mar 17, 2022 4:44 pm
by Cu Penny Hoarder
Searched only 1 box today. Some decent finds...

- 3 war nickels (a record for one box)
- 1 Buffalo 1936 in VG
- 1 V nickel 1902 (definitely looks 120 years old, lots of crud, but date was readable)
- 20 were pre-1960.

And we'll have fun, fun, fun until the gubmint takes the nickels away.

Re: nickels worth keeping

PostPosted: Mon Mar 21, 2022 10:16 pm
by Silver4face
It is good to see that nickels from the 50's are obtaining numismatic value/interest. I recently saw an ad on Craigslist where somebody is looking to buy pre 1960 nickels. He obviously isn't interested in melt value because he can buy those for face. Don't know what he's paying, but obviously it's more than face. In the past, coin dealers/shops etc generally consider the late 40's/50's nickels to be junk. I've even gotten them in change from two different shops. But if people are willing to pay more than face, then they are definitely worth keeping , even WITHOUT the metal factor.

Re: nickels worth keeping

PostPosted: Tue Mar 22, 2022 2:10 pm
by Recyclersteve
Knowing how hard the 2009 nickels and dimes are to find is one thing.

Finding someone willing to buy decent quantities at, say, several times face at a coin show is much more meaningful to me.