Page 3 of 6

Re: My PCGS Submission Results. Updated 11-15-11

PostPosted: Tue Nov 15, 2011 6:18 pm
by Rodebaugh
daviscfad wrote:so doc did you send this stuff economy? i sent some stuff at the end of october and the status still says processing. How long does it usually take?


Regular.....I knew there may be some high dollar coins in there and wanted to be in the correct tier

They got them the 25th of oct...............15 business days on the nose to get my grades back.

Re: My PCGS Submission Results. Updated 11-15-11

PostPosted: Tue Nov 15, 2011 6:28 pm
by Rodebaugh
I just did some research on the Population reports on PCGS and found that I now own a top pop Morgan. Tied as one of the finest 1880-0 DMPL ever graded by PCGS.

MS-64dmpl (39 coins)
MS-65dmpl (0 coins)

Re: My PCGS Submission Results. Updated 11-15-11

PostPosted: Tue Nov 15, 2011 6:38 pm
by Market Harmony
Rodebaugh wrote:I just did some research on the Population reports on PCGS and found that I now own a top pop Morgan. Tied as one of the finest 1880-0 DMPL ever graded by PCGS.

MS-64dmpl (39 coins)
MS-65dmpl (0 coins)


That is just AWESOME, Doc. Congrats on the great find and I'll try to let my jealousy subside overnight. But, if you want to donate that 80-O 64DMPL to the 13, I'll give you the coin I trade out :lol:

Re: My PCGS Submission Results. Updated 11-15-11

PostPosted: Tue Nov 15, 2011 6:40 pm
by daviscfad
Rodebaugh wrote:
daviscfad wrote:so doc did you send this stuff economy? i sent some stuff at the end of october and the status still says processing. How long does it usually take?


Regular.....I knew there may be some high dollar coins in there and wanted to be in the correct tier

They got them the 25th of oct...............15 business days on the nose to get my grades back.


I thought i sent mine regular but she said the turnaround would be 21 business days.

Re: My PCGS Submission Results. Updated 11-15-11

PostPosted: Tue Nov 15, 2011 9:42 pm
by barrytrot
That is terrific news on the submission Rodebaugh.

However: You are probably giving people the impression that sending in coins for grading MAKES MONEY :) Very few have the terrific eye for coins you have and most lose money on the grading proposition, especially on a crack out! :)

Re: My PCGS Submission Results. Updated 11-15-11

PostPosted: Tue Nov 15, 2011 9:49 pm
by Thogey
How bout a picture?!

Re: My PCGS Submission Results. Updated 11-15-11

PostPosted: Tue Nov 15, 2011 9:53 pm
by Rodebaugh
Thogey wrote:How bout a picture?!


Coins Still in Californy.....Pics to be added when they get here.

Re: My PCGS Submission Results. Updated 11-15-11

PostPosted: Wed Nov 16, 2011 1:39 pm
by ScottyTX
Oh wow, what a jump on that DMPL, I been waiting for your results to be posted and may I say congrats!!! Man 823.00 bucks (plus grading costs) for an 1880-O 64 DMPL hummm.... I would of had to do my victory dance around the house a few times as my wife has seen a few times in the past!!!!!

Re: My PCGS Submission Results. Updated 11-15-11

PostPosted: Fri Nov 18, 2011 10:28 pm
by Rodebaugh
Yeah thanks Scott. Gotta saver the homeruns as they are few and far between.

Image

Image

Re: My PCGS Submission Results. Updated 11-15-11

PostPosted: Tue Nov 22, 2011 11:02 am
by dan53
Hey Rode. Great coins! I recently put down some of what I have and I thought maybe it would be ok if we compared some of our collections? If not, let me know. Here's some of mine:



Anacs slabs:

1. 1878 7/8 tf's MS-62 Morgan
2. 1880-o AU-58 Morgan
3. 1881-o MS-61 Morgan
4. 1883-o MS-61 Morgan
5. 1885 MS-62 Morgan
6. 1887 MS-65 Morgan
7. 1887 MS-65 Morgan
8. 1890-s AU-58 Morgan
9. 1896 MS-62 Morgan
10. 1897 MS-63 Morgan
11. 1898 MS-63 Morgan
12. 1900-o MS-65 Morgan
13. 1904-o MS-62 Morgan
14. 1923 AU-58 Buffalo Nickel
15. 1926 MS-61 Standing liberty Quarter
16. 1927 MS-64 Peace dollar
17. 1937 MS-65 FB Mercury Dime
18. 1943-d MS-66 Lincoln Zinc Penny
19. 1948-d MS-64 FBL Franklin Half dollar
20. 1949-d MS-63 FBL Franklin Half dollar
21. 1964 PF-66 Kennedy Half dollar Proof

NGC slabs:

1. 1881-s MS-63 PL Morgan
2. 1882-cc MS-61 Morgan
3. 1882-s MS-65 Morgan
4. 1886 MS-65 Morgan
5. 1887 MS-65 Morgan
6. 1890 MS-64 Morgan
7. 1898-o MS-65 Morgan
8. 1903-o MS-64 Morgan
9. 1938-s MS-64 Mercury Dime
10. 1944-d MS-66 FB Mercury Dime
11. 1950 AU-55 Franklin Half dollar
12. 1960-d MS-64 FBL Franklin Half dollar
13. 2010 Eagle 1/10 oz AU MS-70

PCGS slabs:

1. 1879-s MS-62 Morgan Rev of 78
2. 1881-s MS-65 Morgan
3. 1885 MS-64 Morgan
4. 1890 MS-64 Morgan
5. 1900 MS-65 Morgan
6. 1903 MS-65 Morgan
7. 1910-s XF-45 Barber Dime
8. 1937 MS-64 FB Mercury Dime
9. 1944-s MS-65 Mercury Dime
10. 1945-d MS-64 FB Mercury Dime
11. 1974-s MS-67 Eisenhauer dollar

ICG slabs:

1. 1897-s MS-65 Morgan
2. 1908 MS-65 Danish 20 Kroner 1/4 oz AU
3. 2000 MS-70 Plat Eagle $10 1/10 oz Plat.

PCI slabs:

1. 1962 PR-67 Franklin Half dollar
2. 1961 PR-68 Deep Cameo Franklin Half dollar

PGS slab:

1. 1963-d MS-70 Franklin Half dollar (coin is over graded)

Trugrade slab:

1. 1961 PR-67 Quarter


Raw coins:

Dollars:

1. 1880-s Morgan UNC
2. 1889 Morgan UNC
3. 1890 Morgan AU
4. 1897 Morgan AU
5. 1898-o Morgan AU
6. 1901-o Morgan AU
7. 1921 Morgan AU
8. 1921 Morgan UNC
9. 1921 Morgan XF
10. 1921 Morgan XF
11. 1923 Peace dollar AU
12. 1963 Canadian dollar
13. 1979 Susan B Anthony "Near Date"

90% silver Half dollars:

1. 1982-d George Washington commemorative UNC
2. 1982-d George Washington commemorative UNC
3. 1964 Kennedys (55)
4. 1964 Kennedy Proofs...(3)
5. Various date Franklins...various conditions...VG-UNC (21)
6. Franklin proofs....(2)
7. Walking liberty halves....(7) various conditions, various dates...no keys

40% silver half dollars:

1. various dates, various conditions...(42)
2. proofs (2)

Non silver proofs:

1. 1989-s
2. 1990-s

Quarters:

1. 1934 AU
2. 1951-s UNC
3. 1952-s AU
4. 1958 AU
5. 1958-d UNC
6. various dates....(9)
7. Proofs....(1)

Dimes:

1. 1891 Liberty seated F
2. Mercury Dimes (5)
3. Roos (8)

Nickels:

1. 1955 Proof
2. 1926 xf
3. 1945-p Vg

Pennies:

1. 1890
2. 1904
3. 1908
4. 1910
5. 1911
6. 1918
7. 1919
8. 1920-d
9. 1927
10. 1929
11. 1930
12. 1934
13. 1935
14. 1936
15. 1937
16. 1938
17. 1940
18. 1947
19. 1959-d
20. 1960-d
21. 1988-s Proof

Tokens:

1. Washington
2. Mckinley

Ingot:

1. 2000 - 4 Oz Ben Franklin Bar .999 silver. Bar looks like $100 bill. COA from The American Historic Society.

Re: My PCGS Submission Results. Updated 11-15-11

PostPosted: Sat Nov 26, 2011 12:54 pm
by Rodebaugh
Dan, Thats a nice roster for sure..

Re: My PCGS Submission Results. Updated 11-15-11

PostPosted: Sat Nov 26, 2011 12:57 pm
by Rodebaugh
These just went out to PCGS today......Modern service.....so its going to be a while until they get graded. COLOR COLOR COLOR!!!!!!! :mrgreen:

Image

Image

Re: My PCGS Submission Results. Updated 11-15-11

PostPosted: Tue Nov 29, 2011 1:04 pm
by Doctor Steuss
Rodebaugh wrote:Yeah thanks Scott. Gotta saver the homeruns as they are few and far between.

Image

Image



This has to be the equivalent of numismatic porn.

Re: My PCGS Submission Updated 11-26-11 NEW COINS!

PostPosted: Tue Nov 29, 2011 1:22 pm
by fasteddy
May I see that photo again...
Rodebaugh wrote:Yeah thanks Scott. Gotta saver the homeruns as they are few and far between.

Image

Image


So nice....looking forward to your next batch of grades.

Re: My PCGS Submission Results. Updated 11-15-11

PostPosted: Tue Nov 29, 2011 3:20 pm
by barrytrot
Rodebaugh wrote:These just went out to PCGS today......Modern service.....so its going to be a while until they get graded. COLOR COLOR COLOR!!!!!!! :mrgreen:

Image

Image


Most of those look questionable to me, but if even 1 is legit it's a win! And since Rodebaugh has an eye to match his perfect nails, I wouldn't be shocked if all of them came back fully graded :)

Re: My PCGS Submission Updated 11-26-11 NEW COINS!

PostPosted: Wed Nov 30, 2011 7:13 pm
by Rodebaugh
Good news from PCGS!!!!!!

PCGS will now accept Crossover submissions to Secure Plus. Standard Secure Plus fees apply plus an additional charge of $10 per coin. The same crossover rules apply as for Standard Crossovers

Re: My PCGS Submission Updated 11-26-11 NEW COINS!

PostPosted: Wed Nov 30, 2011 7:23 pm
by 68Camaro
Absolutely! Great!!!

(I have no idea what it means, but I'm happy for you. :) )

Re: My PCGS Submission Updated 11-26-11 NEW COINS!

PostPosted: Sun Dec 04, 2011 11:12 am
by dan53
Rode, I'm still looking for a DMPL morgan. I bought one....a 1878-s MS64DMPL, but I wasn't happy with it and had to return it. It had the mirror like fields but lacked the cameo effect on lady liberty. I think its the contrast between the fields and the cameo surface of lady liberty (like your coin) that makes a DMPL so eye appealing.

Re: My PCGS Submission Updated 11-26-11 NEW COINS!

PostPosted: Tue Dec 20, 2011 7:40 pm
by Rodebaugh
Grades are in............all Code 91 :cry:

Well crap.......If any submit is to do poorly it was this one :lol:

Re: My PCGS Submission Updated 11-26-11 NEW COINS!

PostPosted: Mon Mar 05, 2012 7:46 pm
by Rodebaugh
Had another homerun submit today with a colorful 1986 ASE :)

I'll get some pics up this week when it gets back home.

Re: My PCGS Submission Updated 11-26-11 NEW COINS!

PostPosted: Wed Mar 07, 2012 3:10 pm
by Rodebaugh
Honest Color :P

Image

Re: My PCGS Submission Updated 11-26-11 NEW COINS!

PostPosted: Wed Mar 07, 2012 5:59 pm
by Engineer
Beautiful coin Doc. What kind of premium do you think that kind of toning would add to the value?

Re: My PCGS Submission Updated 11-26-11 NEW COINS!

PostPosted: Wed Mar 07, 2012 8:48 pm
by Rodebaugh
Engineer wrote:Beautiful coin Doc. What kind of premium do you think that kind of toning would add to the value?


Thanks E, and Darn good question. I don't think it's one of the super star toners you see on feeBay but it should bring 2-5x the value of a bright white example.

............at least I hope :P

Re: My PCGS Submission Updated 11-26-11 NEW COINS!

PostPosted: Wed Mar 07, 2012 10:21 pm
by Engineer
Thanks Doc. That's about what I would have guessed, but it's nice to get confirmation from somebody with your experience.

Re: My PCGS Submission Updated 11-26-11 NEW COINS!

PostPosted: Wed Mar 07, 2012 10:53 pm
by barrytrot
Toned coins are ALL over the place. And when selling aim high, that's for sure :)

I've bought toned coins for years off and on, and I only wish I had bought more as they seem to appreciate in value continually as long as they are nicely toned. And TPTB don't seem to want to stop it :)

When/if you sell this, Doc, make sure you put a reserve in there and have patience as STRONG STRONG buyers are out there!

As a final thought to show the strength of toned coins: I recently paid 150 times guide for a couple coins! Which might mean I'm over paying, of course, but I am happy I did :)