Cleaned or not cleaned, I'm really not sure.

[JobIII]

Hi All,

Just trying to make sense of something that bothered me this weekend. Came across 2 rolls of really nice looking silver coins, that looked too nice.

If you have a roll of cleaned silver coins is that basically just bullion?

Also aside from cartwheeling is there any other method to determine if a really nice looking coin is authentic or cleaned? The asking price on them would be melt value, should that be a dead giveaway?

~JobIII

[Metals Mogul]

If they aren't askign a premium over melt, I don't see the problem.

[JobIII]

I'm actually more concerned with reselling them. Though I guess I could just say please see photo and be the judge of the coins grade/value.