Page 1 of 3

Store Bans Pennies

PostPosted: Wed May 23, 2012 6:13 pm
by Josh.
http://www.miamiherald.com/2012/05/16/2 ... nnies.html

Some interesting stuff in this article.

Re: Store Bans Pennies

PostPosted: Wed May 23, 2012 7:27 pm
by ceddy2
I agree with this sentiment. It is high time our government quit producing pennies and losing money on each one made. They could then leave it up to individual retailers to decide whether they'll continue to accept them or not. The hoarders will cull out the copper, the zinc will get circulated or, well, who cares?

Re: Store Bans Pennies

PostPosted: Wed May 23, 2012 7:30 pm
by Bigsarge
“The bookkeepers used to come down and say your cash drawer was off by a penny,’’ said Andy Haase, an owner and president of the 84-year-old store off of U.S. 1. “It was just a lot of work for nothing.”


Now it's going to be, "your cash drawer is off by a nickel"?

Re: Store Bans Pennies

PostPosted: Wed May 23, 2012 7:41 pm
by John_doe
more for us. :D

Re: Store Bans Pennies

PostPosted: Wed May 23, 2012 7:57 pm
by RD5
Great article, I was able to read the whole thing :lol:

Re: Store Bans Pennies

PostPosted: Wed May 23, 2012 9:03 pm
by jacer333
It's nice to see the store rounding down in favor of the customer, I figured that almost every store would round up in their own favor.

Re: Store Bans Pennies

PostPosted: Wed May 23, 2012 9:42 pm
by scyther
jacer333 wrote:It's nice to see the store rounding down in favor of the customer, I figured that almost every store would round up in their own favor.

They probably would if it become universal. But this way they can prevent customers from complaining about it.

Re: Store Bans Pennies

PostPosted: Thu May 24, 2012 8:27 am
by Gobirds66
While I agree that the penny and the nickel do cost more to make than the face value, there are several things that critics of producing a penny fail to acknowledge.

1. Pennies last much longer than a year or two in circulation. We all know that we are still pulling about 25% from circulation that are pre -1982 Copper as well as Wheats and occasionally a Chief.

2. Cost of all coins outside of the penny and nickel, as well as all bills have a considerable face value over cost to produce. In other words, the government makes money when it produces them.

3. We are still using the dollar bill which has a considerably lower shelf life than any coin out there. I find many wheats in a box regularly, dating back to the teens. I cannot tell you the last time I found a dollar older than the late 60"s.

So, if this country wants to do away with the penny.....OK, but then the country should force the dollar coin on the public. I have been overseas and seen the dollar coin work well. The reason it does not work here is two fold. 1.) We did not take bills out of circulation to force it and 2.) there is no two dollar coin. Americans never liked the two dollar bill, so they will not like a two dollar coin unless the only alternative is a heavy pocket full of dollar coins. If we produce a two dollar coin, we now have a place for President Lincoln to flee from the penny.

The penny and the nickel do add up. My boss rounded my billable rate down a nickel to the even dollar and I made him put it back in because over the course of a year, that extra nickel per hour amount to roughly ninety bucks. If you throw away that nickel, you throw away 90 bucks, and if you want to throw it away, throw it my way!

As long as we have the cash/coin system, the penny and the nickel should be made. Just my two cents worth (which will go up to 10 cents if we get rid of the nickel and the penny. :D )

Re: Store Bans Pennies

PostPosted: Thu May 24, 2012 12:30 pm
by scyther
Gobirds66 wrote:If we produce a two dollar coin, we now have a place for President Lincoln to flee from the penny.

I've never really understood this concern... He's already on the $5 bill. Why have him on 2 coins/bills in a row?

Re: Store Bans Pennies

PostPosted: Thu May 24, 2012 2:16 pm
by Gobirds66
I never really understood the concern either, but some feel that is a concern so I offer a way to eliminate that concern.

Re: Store Bans Pennies

PostPosted: Thu May 24, 2012 4:55 pm
by creshka46
Gobirds66 wrote:If we produce a two dollar coin, we now have a place for President Lincoln to flee from the penny.


Here's an idea, what if we brought back the quarter eagle and had a $2.50 coin. That would be cool, no? I'm sure everyone would HATE it except for people like us. :)

Re: Store Bans Pennies

PostPosted: Thu May 24, 2012 6:05 pm
by cesariojpn
Gobirds66 wrote:Americans never liked the two dollar bill,


The strippers at the strip clubs beg to differ!!

Re: Store Bans Pennies

PostPosted: Thu May 24, 2012 8:33 pm
by mtalbot_ca
cesariojpn wrote:
Gobirds66 wrote:Americans never liked the two dollar bill,


The strippers at the strip clubs beg to differ!!


Being from Canada, I always thought that it was an urban legend.

Re: Store Bans Pennies

PostPosted: Thu May 24, 2012 10:46 pm
by cesariojpn
mtalbot_ca wrote:
cesariojpn wrote:
Gobirds66 wrote:Americans never liked the two dollar bill,


The strippers at the strip clubs beg to differ!!


Being from Canada, I always thought that it was an urban legend.


BEST NIGHT I EVER HAD!! Had a wad of $2 bills I used as "emergency money," and after several years, I figured swap it out for a prepaid Visa Gift Credit Card, and spend it.

It was a great night.

Re: Store Bans Pennies

PostPosted: Thu May 24, 2012 11:26 pm
by penny pretty
Nice post for a new member josh, and WELCOME!

Re: Store Bans Pennies

PostPosted: Fri May 25, 2012 7:48 am
by Bluegill
mtalbot_ca wrote:
cesariojpn wrote:
Gobirds66 wrote:Americans never liked the two dollar bill,


The strippers at the strip clubs beg to differ!!


Being from Canada, I always thought that it was an urban legend.


Oh no. The novelty from lack of general circulation here in the U,S. made $2 notes more popular and appreciated than $5 notes. Ike's on the other hand, got mixed results. Image

Re: Store Bans Pennies

PostPosted: Fri May 25, 2012 10:50 am
by Gobirds66
Novel, yes. Popular...not so sure. If they were popular, they would not be novel, they would be in circulation. IMO, the reason people save two dollar bills is because they are perceived to be rare. My grandfather saved every darn $2 FRN he ever got and most were in an almost or uncirculated state. I went to the LCS whom I trust very much and he told me their worth.....$2. Apparently there are vaults somewhere stacked with uncirculated $2 bills.... The only bills he were interested in were consecutive serial numbers, the star notes, and the silver certificates. Apparently they have value over face.

Personally, I would love to use the $2 bill more. I like it, but then again, I like Ike and the rest of the dead president dollar coins too.... :)

Re: Store Bans Pennies

PostPosted: Fri May 25, 2012 12:44 pm
by Copper Catcher

Re: Store Bans Pennies

PostPosted: Fri May 25, 2012 5:08 pm
by cesariojpn
Gobirds66 wrote:Personally, I would love to use the $2 bill more. I like it, but then again, I like Ike and the rest of the dead president dollar coins too.... :)


Still can get them from banks.....grudgingly.

Re: Store Bans Pennies

PostPosted: Fri May 25, 2012 5:13 pm
by 68Camaro
cesariojpn wrote:
Gobirds66 wrote:Personally, I would love to use the $2 bill more. I like it, but then again, I like Ike and the rest of the dead president dollar coins too.... :)


Still can get them from banks.....grudgingly.


If your bank is friendly they can/will order them for you. I bought $4000 worth many months back to help out my then head teller, who had ordered them for someone who had decided not to take them. Apparently having the vault teller order unusual cash (which costs money) unusually is frowned on by the bank PTB, so he didn't want to turn it back in. So I took them (at face of course), and gradually got rid of them for him. :)

Re: Store Bans Pennies

PostPosted: Fri May 25, 2012 5:39 pm
by Bluegill
Gobirds66 wrote:Novel, yes. Popular...not so sure. If they were popular, they would not be novel, they would be in circulation. IMO, the reason people save two dollar bills is because they are perceived to be rare. My grandfather saved every darn $2 FRN he ever got and most were in an almost or uncirculated state. I went to the LCS whom I trust very much and he told me their worth.....$2. Apparently there are vaults somewhere stacked with uncirculated $2 bills.... The only bills he were interested in were consecutive serial numbers, the star notes, and the silver certificates. Apparently they have value over face.

I was talking about inside the strip club... Image

Re: Store Bans Pennies

PostPosted: Fri May 25, 2012 6:42 pm
by chris6084
Copper Catcher wrote:Image
Posted at a California bike shop
http://mikesbikes.com/about/pennies-don ... -pg952.htm


The average person wastes 2.4 hours a year dealing with pennies. I waste more than that each week. :lol:

Re: Store Bans Pennies

PostPosted: Fri May 25, 2012 6:45 pm
by chris6084
Gobirds66 wrote:Novel, yes. Popular...not so sure. If they were popular, they would not be novel, they would be in circulation. IMO, the reason people save two dollar bills is because they are perceived to be rare. My grandfather saved every darn $2 FRN he ever got and most were in an almost or uncirculated state. I went to the LCS whom I trust very much and he told me their worth.....$2. Apparently there are vaults somewhere stacked with uncirculated $2 bills.... The only bills he were interested in were consecutive serial numbers, the star notes, and the silver certificates. Apparently they have value over face.

Personally, I would love to use the $2 bill more. I like it, but then again, I like Ike and the rest of the dead president dollar coins too.... :)



There are probably stacks of them at the Bureau of printing and engraving. When I went on a tour of the one in Fort Worth, they talked about $2 bills. They have not printed $2 bills for many years, because nobody uses/needs them. If people did, and banks were ordering them, they would fire up the presses again and start printing more $2 bills.

Re: Store Bans Pennies

PostPosted: Fri May 25, 2012 7:57 pm
by Copper Catcher
This past week I had a friendly teller save for me two red sealed $2 bills. Meh, worth $2.10 maybe each, still neat to see. It is great to have folks looking out for you on everything that they take in. :D

Re: Store Bans Pennies

PostPosted: Mon May 28, 2012 1:37 am
by HoardCopperByTheTon
chris6084 wrote:
Copper Catcher wrote:Image
Posted at a California bike shop
http://mikesbikes.com/about/pennies-don ... -pg952.htm


The average person wastes 2.4 hours a year dealing with pennies. I waste more than that each week. :lol:

Darn.. I just realized I am wasting 2.4 hours a year dealing with pennies. :mrgreen: