by 68Camaro » Sat Aug 06, 2011 7:00 am
Slept on this; I was emotionally and physically wiped out yesterday (the market only part of it).
The points above are all true (at least the valid ones, but I won't go into every one).
a) I don't know what happens when only one agency downgrades, and the others don't. Good point. However, S&P is an important one. (And Zandi is in the pocket of the government; one of the reasons Moody has delayed downgrading.)
b) Yes, this was inevitable, but the timing really sucked. Not the time of day, but given that it was at the end of a sell-off week.
c) To a question on this - major financial announcements are always made after market close, so as to not disrupt the market.
d) The greatest near-term impact is psychological - investor confidence. It also could stimulate or embolden an economic take-down move on the part of another government with ill-well toward us. Russia, China, etc. It will further simulate interest in finding a new reserve currency. Or creating a new global currency.
e) Yes, this only affects new debt. But the amount of new debt we will borrowing in the next 10 years is nearly equal to our total old debt. Plus the old debt revolves - it has various terms, short, middle, long. And as pointed out above, all the shorter-term debt will have to be re-borrowed, now at higher rates. Which has the "knock-on" effect of further increasing our debt, since the cost of borrowing will now be higher.
f) I would expect interest in the dollar to be related to this, so near-term I expect the dollar to fall. Whether that continues depends on whether or not the other major current reserve currencies do better or worse than the dollar, so that may not be saying much. The Euro is in a world of hurt, as is the pound and yen. So the dollar index may not stay down as long as the rest of the world (at least those involved in the major indices) sucks as bad or worse as we do. If the Germans hadn't gone with the Euro and still had their mark, they would be the safe haven currency. As it is, the Swiss Franc is looking better and better, such as that is.
g) If things go down badly all over, then PMs may go "down" as well. But here's the thing. The really important measure is - what will PM buy, in real goods? That may take some time to shake out and mature. Keep reminding yourselves that all these reported financial measures are in terms of fiat currencies that have no current ties to anything solid. The dollar is the keystone to this ponzi scheme. Yank it out, and the whole thing comes falling down. (And they know this, so TPTB will be doing all the can to prop it up near-term.) But no matter what these fiat currencies do, it's what PMs buy in real goods that matter.
In the game of Woke, the goal posts can be moved at any moment, the penalties will apply retroactively and claims of fairness will always lose out to the perpetual right to claim offense.... Bret Stephens
The further a society drifts from the truth, the more it will hate those that speak it. George Orwell.
We can ignore reality, but we cannot ignore the consequences of ignoring reality. Ayn Rand.