BWR’s vs. CWR’s

[Recyclersteve]

I’ve started this thread to discuss BWR’s (bank wrapped rolls) versus CWR’s (customer wrapped rolls).

I’ve never really formally tracked how many of each type of roll I get. I’m assuming those who have a preference would rather get CWR’s as they might get virgin rolls with lots of good dates. I get that- in theory.

Who has actually tracked both roll types to see which is better and how much better?

I’m staring at $13 face in rolled pennies as we speak. $6 are CWR’s and $7 are BWR’s. It would be a royal pain to separate everything (according to BWR and CWR) and report multiple sets of numbers.

And comments you might have would be appreciated.

[cwgii]

Someone put it well, recently.

BWR ,due to the,,,blending,, of coin from many sources ,,,should,, yield ,,,some,, keepers consistently. Flip side, getting whole boxes of new ,freshly minted.

Policy varies from branch to branch. One will ,Only, give out BWR. Yet others, love to give you the cwr, so they do not have to break it,to ship out. Then there was the one recently that refused to sell my the cwr they were in the process, right in front of me, breaking.

Go figure

While cwr are more feast or famine.
I recently got $12 that were 100% zinc.
A couple months ago, I got rolls that were 90% wheats. Crap shoot.

[Silver4face]

I'm surprised this thread wasn't started earlier, especially considering how long this site has been around. But I need to point out that I specifically commented on this issue while posting in another thread just last week. In my comments, I said that BWR's were like singles hitters while CWR's were power hitters who also strike out a lot. For example, I opened a roll of PURE WAR NICKELS 4 years ago, obviously CWR. However, roughly 70 percent of wars are from BWR's.

[Silver4face]

Bump!! Feel the need to comment here. For half dollars, CWR clearly works better for me. I have pulled only ONE silver half from a bwr in my years of doing this. For nickels, I am now giving a slight edge to bwr based on recent results. I have competitors in my area (they mark their rolls too). Their junk often gets into unmarked CWRs. Pennies are all over the map. I can't comment on dimes, quarters or small dollars because I do not search them.

[Recyclersteve]

Silver4Face, thanks for that!